Not quite as good as "A Modern Witch". Probably in part because now I knew what quality of book to expect, and in part because I wasn't quite as smitten by Elorie as I was by Lauren.Still a delightful book though, and I read it in one day. It's lovely to read a book where people are just genuinely nice towards one another. There's no major conflict, no big climax - just a cozy feeling of getting to know a particular group of people. Some people may miss the presence of an actual plot, but I love it :)